The New York Times, December 18, 2023
In 2015, while working as an undergraduate researcher at the North Carolina Zoo, Laura Lewis became friends with a male chimpanzee named Kendall. Whenever she visited the chimps, Kendall would gently take her hands and inspect her fingernails.
Then she disappeared for the summer to study baboons in Africa. When she returned to North Carolina, she wondered if Kendall would still remember her face. Sure enough, as soon as she stepped into his enclosure, Kendall raced up and gestured to look at her hands.
“The feeling I got was that he clearly remembered me after four months away,” said Dr. Lewis, now a comparative psychologist at the University of California, Berkeley. “But I didn’t have the data to prove it.”
Now she believes that she does. In a study published on Monday, Dr. Lewis and her colleagues have demonstrated that chimpanzees and bonobos can recall faces of other apes that they have not seen for years. One bonobo recognized a face after 26 years — a record for facial memory beyond our species.
With the help of her advisor, Chris Krupenye, now at Johns Hopkins University, Dr. Lewis started studying 26 apes kept at the Edinburgh Zoo in Scotland, the Kumamoto Sanctuary in Japan and the Planckendael Zoo in Belgium. At each facility, the researchers rolled up a computer to the apes’ enclosure fence and displayed images of animals on the monitor. A straw attached to the fence allowed the apes to drink juice as they gazed at the photos.
After giving the apes a few months to acclimate to the unusual setup, Dr. Lewis and her colleagues began their experiment. As the animals sipped their juice, the computer displayed pairs of ape faces for three seconds at a time. In every pair, one of the faces was a stranger and the other an old companion whom the ape had not seen for years.
The scientists used an infrared camera to film the animals’ eye movements. If the apes had no memory of their old companions, the scientists expected them to spend equal time glancing at both pictures.
But that’s not what the researchers found. The apes consistently spent more time looking at their former companions. (Kinship played no part in the results, as unrelated past acquaintances also got more attention than strangers did.)
A 46-year-old bonobo named Louise at the Kumamoto Sanctuary demonstrated the oldest memories. Until 1992, she lived at the San Diego Zoo with her sister and her nephew. Then she moved to the Cincinnati Zoo before coming to the Kumamoto Sanctuary in 2014. In 2019, Dr. Lewis and her colleagues found that Louise gazed longer at her long-lost relatives’ faces than at those of apes she had never met, even after being separated for over 26 years.
Dr. Lewis cautioned that tracking eye movements only gives a limited glimpse inside the minds of the apes. “We can’t fully characterize what their memories look like,” she said.
But the researchers did find one tantalizing clue suggesting that fond memories might remain strong over the years. The apes spent a little more time looking at the faces of animals they once had positive experiences with, according to ratings submitted by zoo caretakers.
Dr. Lewis speculates that apes might benefit from these durable memories. A female bonobo, for example, will typically leave her mother’s group to join another group for the rest of her life. If the two groups encounter one another years later, she may be able to form an alliance with old acquaintances.
The experiment doesn’t put a limit on the duration of the animals’ memories. It’s possible that they remember faces as long as we do. In one study, psychologists asked volunteers to name people in photos from their high school yearbooks. Their memories started to decline after 15 years, but some volunteers could still correctly name classmates 48 years after graduation.
Just how many other species have these long-lived memories is hard to say. Jason Bruck, an ethologist at Stephen F. Austin State University in Nacogdoches, Texas, has found that dolphins can recognize the calls of other dolphins that they have not heard for over 20 years.
Dr. Bruck suspects that other long-lived animals that live in groups will also display impressive memories — if scientists can get the opportunity to test them. “I think all these animals will have lifelong memories,” he said.
Dr. Lewis observed that chimpanzees, bonobos and humans all share a common ancestor that lived about seven million years ago. Early humans may have built on the foundation of long-term memories seen in apes as their societies grew more complex.
“In our human evolution, we’ve faced environments where we’re living socially, but not around each other all the time, and populations are further and further spread apart,” she said.
Clive Gamble, an archaeologist at the University of Southampton in England, who was not involved in the new study, agreed with that interpretation. The evolution of language may have strengthened long-lasting social memories, as people told stories about acquaintances they had not seen for years. “We just used our common ancestry, and then cranked up the volume,” Dr. Gamble said.
Copyright 2023 The New York Times Company. Reprinted with permission.