My comment policy at the Loom can be summed up with three words: light but firm.
Science writing often triggers intense reactions in readers–whether the subject is evolution, the biology of the brain, global warming, or genetic engineering. I believe readers should feel free to express those reactions–within reason–on my blog.
I actually find many of these comments useful to my own work. Sometimes people fact-check me and show me where I’ve made a mistake. Other times, they point me to a line of research that’s new to me. I’ve actually ended up writing magazine articles based on those helpful suggestions. (There is no copy-editor looking at this blog, so I appreciate notes about typos, which I will remedy quickly.)